VOL. 3, Issue 12

December 2024

Scottish Rite

The Ashlar

Valley of Columbus, Orient of Georgia

Serving Scottish Rite Masons in the Chattahoochee Valley

Cameron J. Davis, 32° KCCH

Fraternally,

Cameron J. Davis, 32° KCCH
European Representative
Valley of Columbus, Ga.
colkm@gascottishrite.org

President
AMSRB-NATO e.V.
Valley of Washington, DC
cameron.davis@amsrb-nato.com

Supreme Council has developed a New Master Craftsman program "Ivory Key" designed to help our new Scottish Rite Brothers make the most of the reunion experience. The course remains free for Scottish Rite candidates and Brothers who have received their 32° within the 60 day window. I highly encourage our new Masters of the Royal Secret to enroll immediately.

European Representative

Comments

Brethren,

As the holiday season envelops us in its warm embrace, I extend heartfelt greetings to all of you—our Masonic family across Europe and beyond. This is a time to reflect on the year gone by, celebrate the joys of the present, and renew our hopes for the future. No matter our individual beliefs or traditions, the season offers an opportunity to come together, share fellowship, and embody the virtues that unite us as Freemasons.

For our Christian Brethren, this sacred season celebrates the birth of Jesus Christ, a symbol of hope, redemption, and divine love. It is a time to cherish family, extend goodwill to all, and reflect on the blessings bestowed upon us. May your Christmas be filled with peace, joy, and a reaffirmation of the values that guide us as Masons and as men.

To our Jewish Brethren, Hanukkah shines as a celebration of perseverance, miracles, and the triumph of light over darkness. As you light the menorah and recall the resilience of the Maccabees, may this season inspire us all to remain steadfast in the face of challenges, to nurture our faith, and to celebrate the miracles in our lives.

For our Muslim Brethren, though the Islamic calendar does not align specific holidays with this time of year, the universal themes of gratitude, charity, and community resonate deeply during the holiday season. Your example reminds us that our shared principles of brotherhood, compassion, and service extend beyond individual traditions.

And to those who approach this season without specific religious observances, the holiday spirit can still be a beacon of joy, generosity, and unity. Whether it’s the sparkle of lights, the laughter of loved ones, or the simple pleasure of giving, your celebrations contribute to the collective beauty of this time of year.

The holiday season is also a time to reflect on the bonds we share as Masons. Though we come from different faiths, cultures, and walks of life, we are united by our commitment to brotherly love, relief, and truth. As we gather in lodge rooms or around holiday tables, let us remember that our differences enrich us, and our shared values bind us together.

I would also like to remind our European Brethren of a very special occasion to celebrate together. The AMSRB-NATO Holiday Banquet will take place on Saturday, 14 December, at the Hotel Schwarzes Roß in Hörblach, Germany. This annual tradition is more than just a meal—it is a time to connect, celebrate our shared journey, and look ahead to the opportunities the new year will bring. Whether you are attending as one of our Valley of Columbus European Brethren or as a member of DC Scottish Rite, I encourage you to join us for an evening of fellowship and festivity. Your presence will make the event all the more meaningful.

As we navigate the joys and challenges of this season, let us strive to embody the principles that make our fraternity unique. Let us be sources of light, bringing hope to those around us. Let us be examples of charity, offering help where it is needed most. And let us foster harmony, building bridges between cultures, faiths, and traditions.

From my family to yours, Gina, Emily, Liam, and I send our warmest wishes for a joyful and meaningful holiday season. May your days be filled with laughter, love, and the warmth of brotherhood. Merry Christmas to those celebrating, Happy Hanukkah to our Jewish Brethren, and joyous holiday wishes to all who embrace the spirit of this season.

College of Freemasonry

Introduction to "The Futuwwa Brotherhoods"

Cameron J. Davis, 8 December 2024

Throughout history, brotherhoods have served as cornerstones of social, spiritual, and ethical development within societies, providing frameworks for communal cohesion and personal growth. Among these, the Futuwwa brotherhoods stand out as unique and multifaceted organizations that arose in medieval Islamic societies. Rooted in the Arabic term "fatā" (meaning "youth" or "young man"), Futuwwa embodies ideals such as bravery, generosity, loyalty, and a sense of justice—virtues that transcended individual character to form the foundation of collective identity.

Evolving over centuries, the Futuwwa brotherhoods bridged pre-Islamic Arab traditions and Islamic religious principles, creating a chivalric code akin to European knighthood while incorporating Sufi spirituality, guild structures, and at times, military organization. They were both revered for their moral ethos and critiqued for their occasional alignment with urban disorder or rebellious militias.

The "The Futuwwa Brotherhoods," written by Bro. Arda Çilingir, 32° delves into the origins, principles, and evolution of the Futuwwa brotherhoods, exploring their impact on social structures and comparing them to other fraternal organizations, such as Freemasonry. By examining the similarities and differences, it illuminates the enduring legacy of these brotherhoods as an exemplar of humanity's quest for ethical excellence and collective solidarity.

The Futuwwa Brotherhoods

The Futuwwa Brotherhoods

by Arda Çilingir, 32°,  digitally published 8 December 2024

The Futuwwa brotherhoods were corporative organizations of young men in Islamic societies, especially in the medieval Near East. The term "Futuwwa", which arose in the 8th century CE, generally means "youth" and refers to the qualities and characteristics of the "young man" (Arabic "fatā," pl. "fityān"). It embodies meanings such as "youthfulness, young manhood, youthful behavior." The Futuwwa brotherhoods represented a widespread and multifaceted phenomenon. The term “Futuwwa” can describe a variety of movements and organizations with distinct orientations.


Concept and Ideals


While the term “Futuwwa” emerged as an abstract concept in the early Middle Ages, its root word "fatā" frequently appears in pre-Islamic Arabic poetry, embodying virtues associated with noblemen, such as generosity and hospitality, alongside bravery and loyalty to one’s tribe. With the rise of Islam, "Futuwwa" acquired a religious aspect, emphasizing the virtues of those who fought in the cause of jihad or embraced the ascetic practices of Sufism. Initially, individual virtues were central, but over time, the fourth caliph and son-in-law of the Prophet, Ali, became the unmatched ideal of the “fatā,” serving as the patron of Futuwwa due to his valor. The phrase “No sword but Dhu'l-Fiqar! No fatā but Ali!” became the motto of Futuwwa circles.


The Kuran also uses "fatā" exclusively in positive contexts, allowing figures like Ibrahim (Abraham), Yusuf (Joseph), or the Companions of the Cave (Ashab al-Kahf) to be viewed as models of Futuwwa. Beyond individual virtues, Futuwwa developed "brotherhood" elements, including rites and rituals for groups of young men committed to common ideals. Initiation rites involved girding with the "pants of Futuwwa" and drinking from the "cup of Futuwwa" filled with salty water, marking one’s entry into an elite-like brotherhood.


Membership progressed through several stages. An applicant first approached a full member for guidance and provisional acceptance. After a probation period, he received a simple apron as a novice and, later, the "pants of Futuwwa" to become a full member. The Futuwwa created a distinct social structure with hierarchical relationships, organized by “younger” and “older” members or familial terms like “son,” “father,” and “grandfather.” This hierarchy constructed ideological lineages tracing back to Ali or even to the Prophet Muhammad.

Alongside this hierarchical order, Futuwwa groups also distinguished between members who pledged only by word and those who had taken the ceremonial drink. Some members also received a sword as part of their commitment, indicating additional responsibilities.


Ideal and Social Reality


As Islam spread, "fityān" (plural of fatā) became a common term for young men’s groups from diverse social, ethnic, and religious backgrounds who bonded independently of family, profession, or tribe. Their ties were marked by solidarity, mutual care, and a community of goods. However, "fityān" were also often associated with social disorder in urban life, seen as vagabonds, wanderers, or lawless groups. Such groups, known as “'Ayyārūn,” sometimes formed gangs that posed social disturbances or even acted as irregular police forces, hired for security roles in the absence of official authority.


By the 11th century, groups of “fityān” and “'Ayyārūn” gained appeal among upper social classes, inspiring literature that idealized Futuwwa values. Sufism also began engaging with Futuwwa; classical virtues were incorporated into Sufi texts, and Futuwwa became closely associated with Sufi ideals.


Historically, Futuwwa evolved into a code of conduct and honor. Frequently described as the “oriental ideal of nobility,” this ideal encompassed a variety of social groups. Futuwwa could signify the Islamic equivalent of European chivalry, brotherhood in Sufi communities, guild-like artisans’ customs, or the esprit de corps of city militias or aristocratic youth clubs. In Persia, Futuwwa also appeared in courtly “mirrors for princes” literature and folklore.


The Futuwwa concept blended diverse influences. Arabs brought the pre-Islamic “fatā” nobleman ideal to the Middle East in the 7th century CE, which evolved into the religious ideal of the jihadi warrior. In conquered lands, it fused with pre-Islamic traditions, particularly the corporate societal structures of the Sasanian Empire in Persia. Artisans in Seleucia-Ctesiphon widely practiced these traditions, including initiation rites through girding, which reflected a Zoroastrian influence.


Some scholars argue that the “'Ayyārūn” militia-like groups of young men in Islamic cities may also have pre-Islamic roots, descended from minor Sasanian nobility or lower aristocracy. Although their social standing declined under the Umayyads, many regained influence during the Abbasid era, reintroducing chivalric ideals. They developed a strong esprit de corps with distinctive etiquette and ethos, gaining a mixed reputation as independent yet respected figures. Persian literature later romanticized these traditions, with “jawānmardī” as a synonym for Futuwwa.


An alternative tradition views “'Ayyārūn” as Futuwwa adherents aligned with voluntary jihadi groups. By the 9th century, Futuwwa included military elements, with Futuwwa organizations combining their original ideals with voluntary militia functions. These groups frequently merged Futuwwa traditions with resistance movements against invaders or local rebellions.

By the 12th century, the Futuwwa had integrated into formal Sufi organizations, guilds, and even military training. Abbasid caliphs like al-Nasir li-Din Allah institutionalized Futuwwa ideals, creating official orders that blended Sufi spirituality, chivalric principles, and state allegiance.

A comparison between the Futuwwa Orders and Freemasonry


A comparison between the Futuwwa Orders and Freemasonry reveals fascinating similarities and differences, as both are brotherhoods that emphasize ethical values and ritual practices. Below is an analysis of the key aspects of both traditions. 


Similarities Between the Futuwwa Orders and Freemasonry



Differences Between the Futuwwa Orders and Freemasonry



Conclusion


The Futuwwa Orders and Freemasonry are both brotherhoods characterized by hierarchical structures, ethical ideals, and ritual traditions. However, the Futuwwa is closely tied to Islamic religion and localized social structures, while Freemasonry has a universal, philosophical approach independent of specific religious traditions. Both reflect humanity’s drive for community, moral growth, and the pursuit of higher ideals, albeit within different historical, cultural, and religious frameworks.

References

Vol. 3, No. 12 - December 2024